Private Internet Access (PIA) is a premium VPN service based in the US that focuses on being simple and easy to use for a target consumer market. Its primary selling features are its no-logging policy and claimed fast network speeds. In addition, it offers subscribers unlimited bandwidth using superfast servers, and the company claims never to throttle speeds. There are currently no data retention laws for services based in the US, unlike other regions such as Europe. Combined with the no-logging policy, this means that, in theory, user privacy should be guaranteed.
The VPN service is implemented using open-source protocols to provide transparency of the integrity of its service to users. Primarily the service can be configured to use OpenVPN or WireGuard, offering the latest and more secure protocols. The VPN service for iOS devices uses IPsec (IKEv2) by default. Subscriptions can be taken out monthly, annually, or on a two-year subscription. The latter offering the best value for money over the long term, currently including an additional two free months. The cost of the basic service compares favorably with other popular premium VPN service providers.
A nice feature is that one subscription covers the simultaneous use of up to ten different devices, making it ideal as a solution for the whole family.
The VPN apps support the most popular devices and platforms, including Windows, macOS, Linux, Android, and iOS. There are also browser extensions available for Chrome, Firefox, and Opera. The VPN apps can be configured quickly and easily, though they were found to offer the most secure operation possible by default. A good feature was the ability to set up devices to automatically use a VPN for all connections via insecure open WiFi connections and to disable the VPN for any connections using a secure WiFi connection. This feature offers automatic security protection for mobile devices when they need it and the best connection speed possible when this additional security is unnecessary.
The PIA VPN service includes an automatic Kill Switch to prevent any data leakage should the VPN connection drop out during use. The PIA service also uses its own DNS servers to avoid possible DNS leaks. These features provide users with high levels of privacy. Accessibility to streaming services such as Netflix and BBC iPlayer are generally suitable for users looking for legitimate access to these services while maintaining browsing history privacy. The PIA VPN service terms of use do not permit the downloading and sharing of illegal material. Where streaming services apply preemptive blocks for VPN services, PIA operates servers that implement port forwarding to bypass such blocks if necessary.
NordVPN is a premium VPN service based in Panama that markets itself as having one of the best performances thanks to its bespoke NordLynx protocol that implements a double Network Address Translation (NAT) system on a WireGuard backbone. Users have the option to switch to using OpenVPN (UDP or TCT) or IKEv2/IPsec if more transparency in the protocol is wanted.
Its primary selling features are its zero-logging policy and claimed super-fast network speeds. It offers subscribers unlimited bandwidth for up to six devices, and the company claims never to throttle speeds. There are currently no data collection and retention laws for services based in Panama, unlike other regions such as Europe. An audit of the logging claim by PricewaterhouseCoopers AG, Zurich, Switzerland reports this policy description is fair and accurate. Combined with this zero-logging policy, this means that, in theory, user privacy should be guaranteed.
Private Internet Access VPN Server Locations | Download | Upload |
---|---|---|
United Kingdom | 173.79 Mbit | 87.37 Mbit |
Australia | 240.41 Mbit | 20.21 Mbit |
China | 340.28 Mbit | 1.4 Mbit |
South Africa | 16.38 Mbit | 35.44 Mbit |
California, USA | 316.32 Mbit | 14.23 Mbit |
New York, USA | 147.4 Mbit | 25.34 Mbit |
Germany | 79.82 Mbit | 149.91 Mbit |
Taiwan | 167.48 Mbit | 0.94 Mbit |
Spain | 82.95 Mbit | 122.37 Mbit |
Brazil | 130.67 Mbit | 30.3 Mbit |
NordVPN VPN Server Locations | Download | Upload |
---|---|---|
United Kingdom | 732.38 Mbit | 352.96 Mbit |
Australia | 148.82 Mbit | 19.61 Mbit |
Taiwan | 81.91 Mbit | 41.36 Mbit |
South Africa | 241.08 Mbit | 15.89 Mbit |
Arizona, USA | 449.54 Mbit | 8.99 Mbit |
New York, USA | 547.48 Mbit | 31.71 Mbit |
Germany | 545.48 Mbit | 96.32 Mbit |
Spain | 632.41 Mbit | 128.17 Mbit |
Brazil | 390.1 Mbit | 26 Mbit |
Indonesia | 124.18 Mbit | 10.54 Mbit |
Private Internet Access VPN Server Locations | Download | Upload |
---|---|---|
United Kingdom | 173.79 Mbit | 87.37 Mbit |
Australia | 240.41 Mbit | 20.21 Mbit |
China | 340.28 Mbit | 1.4 Mbit |
South Africa | 16.38 Mbit | 35.44 Mbit |
California, USA | 316.32 Mbit | 14.23 Mbit |
New York, USA | 147.4 Mbit | 25.34 Mbit |
Germany | 79.82 Mbit | 149.91 Mbit |
Taiwan | 167.48 Mbit | 0.94 Mbit |
Spain | 82.95 Mbit | 122.37 Mbit |
Brazil | 130.67 Mbit | 30.3 Mbit |
NordVPN VPN Server Locations | Download | Upload |
---|---|---|
United Kingdom | 732.38 Mbit | 352.96 Mbit |
Australia | 148.82 Mbit | 19.61 Mbit |
Taiwan | 81.91 Mbit | 41.36 Mbit |
South Africa | 241.08 Mbit | 15.89 Mbit |
Arizona, USA | 449.54 Mbit | 8.99 Mbit |
New York, USA | 547.48 Mbit | 31.71 Mbit |
Germany | 545.48 Mbit | 96.32 Mbit |
Spain | 632.41 Mbit | 128.17 Mbit |
Brazil | 390.1 Mbit | 26 Mbit |
Indonesia | 124.18 Mbit | 10.54 Mbit |
So, let’s put PIA and NordVPN side by side. Here, you can put a comprehensive comparison, including privacy and security features, speed, streaming, compatibility, and support. At last, you can compare the providers in price, and decide whichever is more worth spending your money.
Let’s check; in which aspects do these differ and up to which degree?
PIA is located in the US, the epicenter of the Five Eyes, which is not that great of news. The authorities can easily knock on the provider’s doors and ask for users’ data. Still, PIA states that it doesn’t gather any activity logs. The authorities have also requested PIA for data on several occasions in the past. Fortunately for you, PIA didn’t comply.
Private Internet Access further protects your privacy, location, and content you access. Better yet, it has a strict no-logs policy, hides your IP address, and allows for anonymous payment methods, third-party gift cards, and cryptocurrencies.
Source: https://www.privateinternetaccess.com/online-privacy
When it comes to NordVPN, you will be able to sleep more peacefully. The VPN is headquartered in a privacy-friendly location in Panama. Sure, PIA is good. However, NordVPN takes things to another level.
It has a much more clear privacy policy. If the authorities ask for data, the VPN will have nothing to show, which is highly reassuring. Even an independent audit by PwC has confirmed this fact!
Furthermore, NordVPN provides multi-factor authentication, masks your IP, KillSwitch, Onion Over VPN, a Dedicated IP, and No data leaks. So, it’s only natural for it to take the lead.
Source: https://nordvpn.com/features/
Every VPN out there will add to your security. The question is, to which degree? At this point, you should look for advanced features to better compare different providers.
PIA uses trusted, open-source VPN protocols, such as OpenVPN and WireGuard. It also has advanced encryption settings, split tunneling, reliable automation rules, built-in ad and malware blocking, and a WireGuard protocol.
NordVPN also comes with WireGuard, ad, and malware blocking. It features double IP protection and obfuscated servers, Tor over VPN, and leak protection.
At first sight, you might think, it’s more or less the same. However, NordVPN truly stands out if you get into the underlying technologies. Thus, it provides better security than PIA.
PIA has a global network with 29,300 P2P, reliable servers in 78 countries, optimized for 10 Gbps and lightning-fast speeds. And the best part is, you can get unlimited bandwidth without throttling the speeds.
Source: https://www.privateinternetaccess.com/vpn-features/fastest-vpn
NordVPN provides fewer servers or a total of 5,190 servers in 60 countries worldwide. Still, it has a better distribution, with locations in the Americas, Europe, Asia Pacific, Africa, Middle East, and India.
Source: https://nordvpn.com/servers/
We tested the two providers in different server locations, where both have a presence, including Los Angeles, Seattle, New York, and the UK. It’s safe to say that NordVPN performed better in all server locations.
With PIA, you can get simultaneous access on up to ten devices on all major apps, such as Windows, macOS, Linux, Android, and Apple iOS. It also works on Chrome, Firefox, and Opera.
Source: https://www.privateinternetaccess.com/vpn-features/fastest-vpn
NordVPN provides a much broader selection, including Playstation, Xbox, Nintendo Switch, firestick, and so on. Better yet, you can install it on your router. If not, it can support up to six devices at the same time.
Source: https://nordvpn.com/download/other/
NordVPN beats PIA in streaming options. It provides uninterrupted streaming without buffering anytime, anywhere. With this VPN, you can enjoy a full range of streaming content, including sports, from official channels.
In turn, PIA might work with US Netflix or unblock YouTube content. Yet, that’s more or less all about it.
You can find all necessary information regarding VPNs in the guides and FAQs from both NordVPN and PIA. Better yet, they both promise 24/7 support.
However, when we got to testing, NordVPN once again won the contest. Its agents were much more friendly and knowledgeable to solve the issues.
As mentioned, the cost of a VPN should be your last priority. Still, it would help if you had a provider that fits your budget.
PIA is the more affordable alternative of the two. However, there’s a price-benefit trade-off, as explained over the review.
Both VPNs come with30-day money-back guarantee policies. So, you can test them out safely, without risking your money. If you are not satisfied with the services, you can always get a refund.
Source: https://nordvpn.com/pricing/
I think it’s pretty clear – NordVPN is the winner. It provides more advanced features than Private Internet Access in most categories, except for the price. Still, keep in mind, we are getting into as many details as possible. PIA is a top-notch provider, and it can also provide a smooth customer experience. So, if it better suits your budget, you might go for it as well!