Private Internet Access (PIA) is a premium VPN service based in the US that focuses on being simple and easy to use for a target consumer market. Its primary selling features are its no-logging policy and claimed fast network speeds. In addition, it offers subscribers unlimited bandwidth using superfast servers, and the company claims never to throttle speeds. There are currently no data retention laws for services based in the US, unlike other regions such as Europe. Combined with the no-logging policy, this means that, in theory, user privacy should be guaranteed.
The VPN service is implemented using open-source protocols to provide transparency of the integrity of its service to users. Primarily the service can be configured to use OpenVPN or WireGuard, offering the latest and more secure protocols. The VPN service for iOS devices uses IPsec (IKEv2) by default. Subscriptions can be taken out monthly, annually, or on a two-year subscription. The latter offering the best value for money over the long term, currently including an additional two free months. The cost of the basic service compares favorably with other popular premium VPN service providers.
A nice feature is that one subscription covers the simultaneous use of up to ten different devices, making it ideal as a solution for the whole family.
The VPN apps support the most popular devices and platforms, including Windows, macOS, Linux, Android, and iOS. There are also browser extensions available for Chrome, Firefox, and Opera. The VPN apps can be configured quickly and easily, though they were found to offer the most secure operation possible by default. A good feature was the ability to set up devices to automatically use a VPN for all connections via insecure open WiFi connections and to disable the VPN for any connections using a secure WiFi connection. This feature offers automatic security protection for mobile devices when they need it and the best connection speed possible when this additional security is unnecessary.
The PIA VPN service includes an automatic Kill Switch to prevent any data leakage should the VPN connection drop out during use. The PIA service also uses its own DNS servers to avoid possible DNS leaks. These features provide users with high levels of privacy. Accessibility to streaming services such as Netflix and BBC iPlayer are generally suitable for users looking for legitimate access to these services while maintaining browsing history privacy. The PIA VPN service terms of use do not permit the downloading and sharing of illegal material. Where streaming services apply preemptive blocks for VPN services, PIA operates servers that implement port forwarding to bypass such blocks if necessary.
ExpressVPN is a premium VPN service based in the British Virgin Islands that markets itself as having one of the best performances thanks to its in-house Lightway protocol. This is a bespoke open-source protocol built on the open-source WolfSSL libraries. This implementation is fully transparent for security researchers looking to validate privacy claims. The Lightway protocol supports both TCP and UDP options. Users have the option to switch to using OpenVPN or IKEv2/IPsec if an alternative protocol is wanted. There is no planned option for ExpressVPN to support WireGuard.
Its primary selling features are its zero-logging policy and claimed high bandwidth, fast network speeds. It offers subscribers unlimited bandwidth for up to five simultaneously connected devices, and the company claims never to throttle speeds. There are currently no data retention laws for services based in the British Virgin Islands, unlike other regions such as Europe. An audit of the privacy policy has been completed by PricewaterhouseCoopers with no issues reported. Combined with its zero-logging policy, this means that, in theory, user privacy should be guaranteed.
Private Internet Access VPN Server Locations | Download | Upload |
---|---|---|
United Kingdom | 173.79 Mbit | 87.37 Mbit |
Australia | 240.41 Mbit | 20.21 Mbit |
China | 340.28 Mbit | 1.4 Mbit |
South Africa | 16.38 Mbit | 35.44 Mbit |
California, USA | 316.32 Mbit | 14.23 Mbit |
New York, USA | 147.4 Mbit | 25.34 Mbit |
Germany | 79.82 Mbit | 149.91 Mbit |
Taiwan | 167.48 Mbit | 0.94 Mbit |
Spain | 82.95 Mbit | 122.37 Mbit |
Brazil | 130.67 Mbit | 30.3 Mbit |
ExpressVPN VPN Server Locations | Download | Upload |
---|---|---|
United Kingdom | 468.98 Mbit | 212.99 Mbit |
Australia | 316.19 Mbit | 18.08 Mbit |
Taiwan | 345.33 Mbit | 25.09 Mbit |
South Africa | 331.56 Mbit | 9.37 Mbit |
California, USA | 354.08 Mbit | 42.8 Mbit |
New York, USA | 400.08 Mbit | 65.08 Mbit |
Germany | 540.43 Mbit | 118.08 Mbit |
Brazil | 411.00 Mbit | 15.49 Mbit |
Private Internet Access VPN Server Locations | Download | Upload |
---|---|---|
United Kingdom | 173.79 Mbit | 87.37 Mbit |
Australia | 240.41 Mbit | 20.21 Mbit |
China | 340.28 Mbit | 1.4 Mbit |
South Africa | 16.38 Mbit | 35.44 Mbit |
California, USA | 316.32 Mbit | 14.23 Mbit |
New York, USA | 147.4 Mbit | 25.34 Mbit |
Germany | 79.82 Mbit | 149.91 Mbit |
Taiwan | 167.48 Mbit | 0.94 Mbit |
Spain | 82.95 Mbit | 122.37 Mbit |
Brazil | 130.67 Mbit | 30.3 Mbit |
ExpressVPN VPN Server Locations | Download | Upload |
---|---|---|
United Kingdom | 468.98 Mbit | 212.99 Mbit |
Australia | 316.19 Mbit | 18.08 Mbit |
Taiwan | 345.33 Mbit | 25.09 Mbit |
South Africa | 331.56 Mbit | 9.37 Mbit |
California, USA | 354.08 Mbit | 42.8 Mbit |
New York, USA | 400.08 Mbit | 65.08 Mbit |
Germany | 540.43 Mbit | 118.08 Mbit |
Brazil | 411.00 Mbit | 15.49 Mbit |
Are there substantial differences between the two? Well, there sure are. While ExpressVPN, as the name implies, is the fast one, PIA is the more affordable option. But that’s not all there is. Let’s get into more details.
ExpressVPN was fast to take the lead. It’s based in the British Virgin Islands, which is an excellent offshore jurisdiction. The VPN is politically and legally independent from external influences. To ensure the highest possible security levels, ExpressVPN also undergoes regular audits. Better yet, it hasn’t been part of any issues and privacy-related scandals in the past.
Unfortunately, we cannot say the same for Private Internet Access. Even though the VPN promises to prioritize its users’ privacy, it’s headquartered in the US. And if you have at least a bit of experience with Virtual Private Networks, you are sure aware; US companies have been forced to hand over customer data a bunch of times in the past.
However, more importantly, both ExpressVPN and PIA claim to keep no activity logs and no connection logs.
ExpressVPN offers the best-in-class 256-bit encryption by default. However, you can also use ChaCha20/Poly1305 encryption with the Lightway protocol. The provider also comes with Network Lock, the ExpressVPN kill switch, VPN split tunneling, TrustedServer security, and private, encrypted DNS.
Private Internet Access provides AES-128 (CBC) as the default option. However, you can also get AES-128 (GCM), AES-256 (CBC), AES-256 (GCM), or no encryption at all (avoid this option at all cost). Furthermore, the VPN comes with PIA MACE, malware filters, and the classic Kill Switch feature.
In short, both providers are remarkable in terms of security features. So, it’s safe to say it’s a tie.
ExpressVPN has 160 servers in 94 countries. The best part about this provider is its well-dispersed network with many locations in the Americas, Europe, Asia Pacific, Middle East, and Africa.
Going on, ExpressVPN supports several tunneling protocols, Lightway, OpenVPN (UDP/TCP), IKEv2/IPsec, and L2TP/IPsec. In turn, PIA VPN provides WireGuard, OpenVPN (UDP/TCP), and IKEv2/IPsec as options.
Source: https://www.expressvpn.com/
In theory, Private Internet Access comes close to ExpressVPN with its 29,300 servers in 78 countries, all of which are physical P2P.
Source: https://www.privateinternetaccess.com/vpn-server
However, in practice, there’s a whole another truth. See, ExpressVPN is one of the fastest providers on the market. So, it’s rare for a VPN even to come close to its quality. And it’s far less likely to exceed it in this regard. Most of all, it’s due to Lightway, ExpressVPN’s in-house tunneling protocol.
Both VPNs are easy to set up and navigate. However, ExpressVPN is incredibly convenient. It works on computers, phones, tablets, routers, browsers, and more. It covers popular solutions, such as Windows, Mac, Android, iOS, Linux, Routers, along with Chrome, Firefox, and Edge. Better yet, it works with Kindle Fire, smart TV systems, Playstation, Xbox, Nintendo Switch, and game consoles.
Private Internet Access is a bit more limited in this regard. It works exclusively with major apps and browsers.
Now, with ExpressVPN, you can simultaneously use a single subscription for up to five devices. PIA VPN takes this to another level, providing better support for up to ten devices.
When it comes to ExpressVPN, you can easily stream and download any content you want. The best part is, it comes with unlimited bandwidth and remarkable speeds. The VPN is compatible with popular streaming apps, such as Netflix, HBO, or Disney+. However, it also works with social media platforms, messaging and tools, games, music, education, and so on.
Source: https://www.expressvpn.com/vpn-service
Unfortunately, PIA is on the whole other side of the spectrum. It falls way behind ExpressVPN since it doesn’t provide any of the mentioned features.
Private Internet Access VPN provides for an extensive Knowledgebase, ticketing system, and live chat option. However, according to customer reviews, the live chat agents might not be as helpful and responsive as they should be.
Luckily, with ExpressVPN, you can get all the support you’ll ever need. The provider has a Knowledgebase, Troubleshooting tool, 24/7 live chat, and email support.
PIA VPN is the clear winner when it comes to pricing. In general, its cost makes PIA different and gives the company an advantage over its competitors.
Source: https://www.privateinternetaccess.com/buy-vpn-online
ExpressVPN is far more expensive, probably among the most costly VPNs on the market.
Source: https://www.expressvpn.com/order
Still, both PIA and ExpressVPN come with 30-day money-back guarantees. So, you can get either of these VPNs, no strings attached.
The race wasn’t even close, and we have a clear winner – ExpressVPN. It provides remarkable privacy, security, and speed. The provider also comes with a nice and comprehensive set of add-ons. It’s excellent for unblocking content, streaming, torrenting, and gaming.
Private Internet Access (PIA), in turn, is too limited in comparison. The only advantage over ExpressVPN is its price. Still, it’s a quality VPN on its own, providing for reliable connections and ease of use.